From Roseto, With Love
100 miles southeast of Rome, lies a
medieval township. Faithful to it's Roman heritage, the town was built around a
large, central square. Directly facing the square, was houses belonging to the
city's nobles. There was a middle-aged archway on one side, that will bring
visitors to the town's church, Madonna del Carmine -Our Lady of Mount
Carmine-. The town was actually established upon the foothills of Apenine near
rural Italy in a province named Foggia. For those who were accustomed to the
area, they will find the town's pavement arranged in the form of narrow stone
steps that run up to the hill side. Flanked in between, was 2-storey stone
houses with a red-tiled roof, sheltering visitors from the gentle warmth of
sunny Foggia. The town's name was Roseto.
Life in Roseto was harsh. The
peasants there commonly worked near the marble quarries around the foothill.
Some went to the terrace valley below, ploughing farm for crops. Each day, they
have to walk 6 to 8 kilometres down the hill in the morning and back up to the
mountain by dusk. Economic betterment was foreign to them. Even, literacy among
the townsfolk was scarce. It was not until 19th century that words reached Roseto, that across the ocean,
a land of opportunity was found.; the Land of America.
January, 1882. 11 Rosetans set to
sail to New York. That following year, 15 more followed suit. Words started to
become promises. Before long, some twelve hundred Rosetans migrated to America
and headed to Pennsylvania, leaving the old town of Roseto empty.
The 'new' Rosetans in America
quickly bought lands near the rocky hillside of Bangor, Pennsylvania. They
started to build the closely clustered 2-storey houses, complete with the
slated, red-tiled roof. They set up a church and called it Our Lady of Mount
Carmine. They farm crops of beans, potatoes and melon in their backyard.
They grow grapes for their homemade wine. They raised pigs and cattles as
nutriment. They organized festivals and
celebrations. You can see that the Rosetans were trying hard to stay true to
their culture. In fact, if you were to stay there in the early 1990's, not only
will you hear pure Italian being spoken, but in precise, the southern and rich
Foggian dialect of Roseto. To an observer, the Rosetans intention was clear;
They are going to build back their home. They are bringing back Roseto.
As inclusive as they can. But not until Stewart Wolf came there and discovered
a peculiar miracle.
Stewart Wolf was a physician. He was
a lecturer, teaching at the medical faculty of Oklahoma University. It was
summer when Wolf was spending his time in a farm right beside Roseto in
Pennsylvania. "I was invited to give
a talk at the local medical society," Wolf said. After the talk was over,
he joined the local doctors for a drink. It was there that he heard the story
of Roseto from one of the doctors; "You know, I've been practicing for 17
years. I get patients from all over, and I rarely find anyone from Roseto under
the age of sixty-five with heart disease". Stewart Wolf was shocked.
Wolf's scene of suprise needed to be
put in a context first. This was 1950's. Years before statins, bile acid
sequestrants, or nicotinic acid agents was introduced. Years before people even
realize the importance of leading a healthy life. No cholesterol-lowering drugs
coupled with the absence of concrete measures to promote robust lifestyle can
only meant one thing; fatal heart disease. Seeing the statistic, it was hard to
guess the other way around. In 1950, nearly half of the causes of death in
America was a direct call from heart disease cases. Common sense dictates that
for a doctor to work in America without bumping into any heart-disease related
patients was effectively zero. To put it in our language, it's like a doctor
working in Kelantan without hearing about any "kencing manis"
case. It just doesn't make any sense.
Stewart Wolf was determined. He
gathered support from his students and colleagues around Oklahoma. They packed
and went to Roseto. The mayor provided the town council room for the purpose.
It was 1961 when they started. "We decided to do preliminary study"
Wolf plans. Their investigation stretched from death certificates, physician's
records, medical histories, and up to a complete family trees. They took samples
of blood and EKG readings from a small pool of the townsfolk. It wasn't enough.
After four weeks, the team moved from the town's council room to the town's
school. Only this time, their sample pools were bigger; The entire
population of Roseto.
The result was astounding. None of
the Rosetans under the age of 55, has ever died from heart attack. They don't
even show any signs of one. Wolf was intrigued. He was challenged, to be exact
. He just couldn't find any explanation. In a nation where heart disease was
-and still is- a serial killer, Roseto seemed immune from it. He grabbed a
phone and call his friend, John Bruhn, a sociologist from Oklahoma. They
decided to change their method of approach."I hired medical students and
sociology grad students as interviewers, and in Roseto we went house to house
and talked to every person aged twenty-one and over," Bruhn recalls a
scene which belongs some 50 years ago. "There was no suicide, no
alcoholism, no drug addiction, and very little crime." Bruhn couldn't hide
his amazement. Rosetans didn't have any other cause of death. They died only
because of old age. That's it.
How you choose your food, the amount
of calories in the food, the nutrients in store, all these are the official
guide of How to Treat Your Heart Disease for Dummies. But to say that the
Rosetans followed a strict diet originating since from Roman age, would be
preposterous. For one thing, the Rosetans foods were cooked with the cheap and
richly-saturated pig fat of lard. Heavily in contrast to the more expensive but
healthier olive oil they used for cooking back in Italy. In Italy, the Rosetans
baked pizza with thin crusts, some onion and anchovies. In Pennsylvania, their
pizza was bread dough plus pepperoni plus ham plus sausage plus salami. Italian
sweets as biscotti, canestrelli and taralli were exclusive
to Christmas and certain festivals back in Italy. While in Roseto, they were
eaten the whole year round. Wolf had once asked dieticians to analyze the
eating habits of Rosetans. They found out that an unbelievable amount of 41% in
their diet was purely fat. If you are what you eat, surely Rosetan didn't seem
like it.
Wolf started to consider hereditary
factor. Genetic similarity or maybe some particular nuclear arrangement. The
Rosetans are basically a self-sufficient group coming from a similar region in
Italy. Maybe they have something in common with the other Southern Italian. A
particular gene perhaps which give them such resilient breed of stock. Wolf
began tracking down the relatives of Rosetan's scattered across America. He was
searching for the invisible ink which may connect the visible dots from Roseto.
Some remarkable attributes of health that they may share with their cousin. He
combed through the list. He calls and send letters to them asking for their
health condition, any form of tangible link that they could recall. Then Wolf
suddenly stops. He cannot find any.
Wolf's team list of options were
narrowing. It wasn't diet, and it was't genetic factor. To credit the Rosetans
habit of exercising would be laughable. Roseto in Foggia and Roseto in
Pennsylvania was different in terms of geography. Here in America, they doesn't
have the same routine of going down and up the mountain for a total of 15
kilometer per day for the obvious reason that they didn't have to. Nor was them
the type of people which rise up early in the morning for yoga or jogging. In
fact, many of them were struggling with obesity. They also smoked heavily.
Again and again, Wolf's chase seemed like a hopeless case.
Wolf held on to what perhaps maybe
his last card. The region of Pennsylvania. What if there was something
special about the foothills here? Something or anything that correlate directly
to the benevolence of Rosetan's health. As a starter, there were only 2 towns
closest to Roseto; Bangor and Nazareth. He noticed that both of them have the same span as Roseto, with the almost
same kind of community that Roseto had. A community of hardworking European
immigrants. Wolf just maybe have found his lucky break. Wolf started scouring
down on the medical records of both town. He then compared them to Roseto's.
Bangor and Nazareth death rates were 3 times that of Roseto. Period. Dead end.
It wasn't too long however, before
Wolf and Bruhn began to realize that they had been looking at the wrong place
from the start. "I remember going to Roseto for the first time, and you'd
see three-generational family meals, all the bakeries, the people walking up
and down the street, sitting on their porches talking to each other, the blouse
mills where the women worked during the day, while the men worked in the slate
quarries. It was magical" Bruhn remembers. It wasn't magic that made the
death rates in Roseto were 35 percent lower than expected. It wasn't magic that
made Rosetans lived twice longer than the national average. It was just
Rosetans being Rosetans.
Such
abstract concept was really alien to the medical society. You can already guess
the wave of cynicals that Wolf and Bruhn met when they presented their findings
to the scientific community. Imagine; here they are, standing in a conference,
where their colleagues bring forth incoherent datas and statistics, trivial
findings of biomarkers, test results of a new pharmaceutical drugs; while Wolf
and Bruhn talking instead about the benefits of a close-knit community,
of people stopping and talking with each other around the corner, of families
of three generations living under one roof caring one another. But no one seems
to giva a damn at that time. Because no one ever saw health in terms of community.
"People are nourished by other people,"
said Wolf. This was a peculiar statement coming out from the mouth of a
physician. People's life depends on their heart. And heart was nourished by
capillary beds, by good circulation of blood., which then extends to our eating
habit, our choice of food, our lifestyle attitude. But Roseto defies logic.
They went a step further. They function
as a whole. Instead of putting their elderly ones "on the shelf",
they were hailed "to the Supreme Court". The young ones who are in
need of guidance, were thus free to express themselves to their elders at home.
They externalized their stress, sharing the weight of their burden with
the people who care them the most; their family. "(They) radiated a kind
of joyous team spirit as they celebrated religious festivals and family
landmarks", Wolf noted. Then, he ends; "In those communities, each
person has a clearly defined role in the social scheme -- toward a common
goal--a better life for their children". Roseto doesn't need good food or
new drugs or strict diet to live longer. Roseto only need Rosetans to be
Rosetans.
What
Wolf saw there in Roseto was definitely beyond the lens of microscope. It
wasn't anything new, though. Nothing revolutionary. It was just a community
functioning as a community. It was just care and affection between members of
family. In Roseto, what Wolf saw was true love in practice. As simple and as
effortless as it can be.
written by:
Ahmad
bin Abdul Rahim
Second
Year Malaysian Student
Faculty
of Medicine, Cairo University
why is this so off the theme?
ReplyDelete-to anon, please define what dou you mean by "so off the theme"
Delete-referring to MeM's rules & reg (http://medicophilicmonth2012.blogspot.com/2012/04/rules-and-regulations-1.html) where it explicitly said to "write the article about science health which (are) related to MEM’s theme"
-IMO, I pretty much think that this article was a health oriented one,
-if u were referring to the 10 titles given, it was actually just a list of RECOMMENDED articles, more like to give participants some sense of direction what kind of article should they write
in your opinioin. ok then =)
ReplyDeletean article or a short story? hmm..
ReplyDeleteto haris fahmi..thnk u for reading. as for ur question, i believe this will do the talking
Deleteen.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_(publishing)
payah juga bila ramai nak jadi pengawas peperiksaan.memang ini satu pertandingan tetapi lebih baik kita melihat apa yang encik ahmad nak sampaikan bukan nya dari segi tema atau tatabahasa
ReplyDelete1) Assalamualaikum guys
ReplyDeletetoday will be the last day for votings
just want to give credit to my critics, and those who "like" it
2) I hope that, through this article, people can get a whole new idea what a scientific article COULD be instead of SHOULD be
because I believe that a good article is a simple article,
because I believe that there are many ways to write an essay
because I believe that scientific article can be made fun & readable, and
because I believe that instead of stuffing facts, maybe you should consider context to give more gist to your writing
Above all, I hope that readers can see all of what I believed sincerely when they read this humble piece of me
Above all of the above, thank you Allah